men riding horses in a rocky valley

Good, Bad, Ugly: What’s New in the ETF world

In the past, talking about ETFs meant talking about low-cost, passive, index-tracking investment products. They were boring, but they were a welcome relief from the world of mutual funds1 and their often sky-high management fees.

Nowadays, ETFs of all stripes are popping up everywhere. And while some continue to adhere to the old tenets of boring, passive and effective, some of them sound like bad ideas, or even worse, sound like something that belongs in a casino. Let’s take a look at a few I’ve taken note of in the last little while.

Good: Scotia’s new all-in-ones

While researching my Gravy train calls on Scotia iTrade, TDDI and TD Easy Trade post, I stumbled across a recently-released family of all-in-ones from Scotia. I’m a big fan of all-in-ones, as they combine hundreds of stocks and bonds in a single product, all with automatic rebalancing. 75% of my RRIF investments are tied up in XGRO, an 80% equity, 20% bond fund, and is the flagship member of my magnificent seven ETFs.

Scotia’s new ETFs are not as obviously named as competitive products (that double-barrelled “SB” for Scotiabank gets in the way), but at least they are staying consistent with the competition:

  • SBEQ2: 100% Equity (43% US3, 25% Canadian4, 22% Developed markets, 10% Emerging Markets)5
  • SBGR6: 80% Equity/ 20% Bonds (34% US, 20% Canadian, 18% Developed, 8% Emerging, 20% Canadian Bonds7)
  • SBBA8: 60% Equity / 40% Bonds
  • SBCN9: 40% Equity/ 60% Bonds

You can review them in greater detail over here.

Anyway, they seem fine, other than being a little too internationally-focused for my liking. But the price is certainly right. They launched in October 2026, and aren’t charging any management fee until October 2027, and a low 0.15% MER thereafter. That’s worth something. And free to trade on all the usual platforms (Wealthsimple, Questrade, BMOI, DisNat) as well as (unsurprisingly) Scotia iTrade.

Bad: So many multi factor ETFs

No doubt inspired by the debut of CAGE (I wrote about this one over at CAGE versus XEQT: what’s the deal?) on the Canadian market, there are now a whole raft of similar sounding ETFs out there.

  • LTCE is a Canadian equity fund that uses “multi-dimensional investment approach that integrates fundamental, quantitative, and trend analysis to identify stocks exhibiting a compelling combination of qualitative merit, attractive financial characteristics, and positive momentum”. MER = 0.60%. Ouch.
  • DSCA is a Canadian equity fund that “uses a systematic investment process that aims to outperform its benchmark index over the long term”10
  • and others…

I dunno, these just seem a way to increase MERs for not very much potential benefit. I’ll stick with passive and boring, I guess.

Ugly: single stock ETFs

Don’t feel like you have enough exposure to Nvidia? There’s an ETF for that! Want 2x performance? That’s NVDL. Want covered call Nvidia? That’s NVDY. Want both? That’s NVII.

Gambling, in my estimation, is best done at a casino. At least you might get a free drink now and then. These ETFs are just gambles on a single stock, and it’s not just limited to Nvidia — I’ve seen similar products trumpeting the wonders of SpaceX, Apple, Alphabet, Tesla… No thanks. I’d rather hold all the stars, and a few dogs along the way as I invest in boring index funds. I sleep well.

  1. My journey as a DIY investor started back while I was still in university when I bought some mutual funds from a “new” company called Altamira. As I recall, I got a presentation from a rep at my parent’s house. Humble times. ↩︎
  2. Competitors: XEQT, VEQT, TEQT, ZEQT ↩︎
  3. All held in SITU, which does NOT track the S&P 500 index, but rather the 500 largest US companies. This sounds suspiciously like the same thing. My AI friends tell me that they may differ “at the margins” (i.e. the smaller of the 500 companies). Maybe I’ll see at some point. ↩︎
  4. Uses SITC, which doesn’t use TSX 60 as the reference index but rather “the 60 largest Canadian companies”. Tomato, tomahto. ↩︎
  5. That’s a very high allocation to equities outside North America. For reference, the other *EQTs stay at a 20% allocation. ↩︎
  6. Competitors: XGRO, VGRO, TGRO, ZGRO ↩︎
  7. All held in SITB: about 75% are government bonds, 25% corporate. ↩︎
  8. Competitors: XBAL, VBAL, TBAL, ZBAL ↩︎
  9. Competitors: XCON, VCNS, TCON, ZCON ↩︎
  10. Aim all you like, but active managers don’t outperform passive indices over time. ↩︎
salesman discussing real estate to a senior couple

What’s it cost to manage your own retirement?

One of the big reasons I became a DIY investor in the first place was to stop paying the typical 1% to 2% annual charges professional money managers charge.

Now before you start scoffing at “small” numbers like 1%, you have to consider a few things

  • 1% of one million dollars1 is $10,000. Retirement savings generally involve relatively large numbers, and small percentages translate into large real dollars. The lineups I see at the gas pumps to save a buck or two on a tank of gas tell me that real dollars are generally more meaningful to people than percentages.
  • Compound interest. Throwing away $10,000 on management fees every year means you’re $10,000 poorer every year. Fast forward ten years at an assumed 6% rate of return, and that $10,000 annual hole turns into (roughly2) ~$135,000 hole
  • …and the most annoying thing? A 100k portfolio is charged the same percentage as a $1M portfolio, meaning the $1M portfolio attracts 10x the fees of the 100k portfolio. Is the $1M portfolio ten times harder to manage? No!

But ok, even a DIYer doesn’t invest for free.

  • If you hold any kind of asset, there’s potentially3 commission fees every time you buy and sell
  • If you hold ETFs (as I do) then the FER4 will cost you, although not explicitly. FERs kick in before you see your own returns.
  • You might pay interest if you borrow money to trade (aka using margin)5
  • You may pay FX fees if you trade in currencies other than CAD6

So let’s look at what my retirement portfolio is actually costing me. For me, that’s now down to FER costs. Using my latest What’s in my retirement portfolio? article, it’s easy enough to calculate. I track in real time how much of each asset I hold, so by looking up the FER and multiplying by $1,000,000, you can get the annual cost :

It’s a bit higher than I expected, admittedly. $1902 is a far cry from the $10,000 I talked about earlier, but it’s not nothing.

I wonder what my rock bottom costs would be? If I were to eliminate all-in-ones (which are convenient, but costly) and just focused on 5 funds, one for cash, one for bonds, one for Canadian equity, one for US Equity and one for International equity, what would I end up with given my asset allocation targets? Here’s that table:

I chose ZAG over XCB because ZAG is a broader bond fund than XCB and diversification is good. I use XCB today because I get broad bond exposure via XGRO. I picked ZST over ZMMK for this exercise, but in reality I would probably still hold ZMMK and ZST in equal proportion. That would lower my overall costs ever so slightly.

I suppose this experiment shouldn’t surprise me: I covered the costs of all-in-ones in a previous post. But this shows that I could cut my annual costs in half should I choose to forgo the convenience of XGRO and XEQT. XGRO would be hard to give up because it makes managing my RRIF accounts (the only place I hold XGRO) much easier. I only sell XGRO to cover my RRIF minimums at the moment, no decisions necessary.

But XEQT I only hold in my long-duration7 TFSA account. There I could possibly make the switch with no real impact other than reducing my fees by about 0.01% or $100 on a million. Something to think about. What about you? Do you pay close attention to MERs/FERs of assets you own? Let me know at comments@moneyengineer.ca!

News: Vanguard reduces fees on their all-in-ones

Summary: Vanguard asset allocation funds aka all-in-one funds VEQT, VGRO, VBAL, VCNS. VSIP have reduced their management fees to 0.17%, down from 0.22%, effective November 18, 2025.

It’s a good time to be an all-in-one investor, as I am. New to all-in-ones? Read all about them here.

The summary pretty much says it all. It just got cheaper to own Vanguard’s all-in-one funds. The amount of the reduction amounts to 50 cents for every $10001 invested per year, but compounded over many years, and multiplied by however much you have saved for retirement, it can be a surprisingly large number.

All-in-ones are much cheaper than either roboadvisors or your typical financial advisor, but as we studied before, they’re not without some cost, so fee reductions are always welcomed. Vanguard joins TD and BMO in reducing the cost of their all-in-ones. We looked at the makeup of each of these funds lately; there’s not a huge amount of difference, no matter which one you pick.

Anyway, you may note that Blackrock’s XEQT/XGRO/XINC family is now the most expensive of the lot; there’s no reason for that to be true given the competitive landscape. I would expect Blackrock to follow suit, or if not, I’ll probably be making some moves to get to lower fees, since a lot of my retirement portfolio is currently tied up in XEQT/XGRO. ZEQT/ZGRO I think is the closest in makeup to the XEQT/XGRO family.

  1. Of course, if you only have $1000 saved for retirement, you have other worries. ↩︎

News: Global X launches new ETFs, lowers fees

New US T-Bill ETFs from Global X

As mentioned elsewhere, I try to keep about 5% of my retirement savings in what I loosely refer to as “cash”. Of course, it’s not cash, cash doesn’t earn any interest, and that would drive me bonkers. Instead, I’ve been using ZMMK and ICSH (two of my ETF all-stars) to serve this purpose. I made a more detailed assessment of available products at the time over here.

But Global X (a company who I do a lot of business with, thanks to XEQT, XGRO and HXT) has launched 4 products that invest solely in US Treasury Bills.

  • TSTX/TSTX.U/TSTX.F: all based on 1-3 year treasury bills, which, in common bond lingo, is “short” duration. TSTX is the one that’s probably of greatest interest to most of you since it trades in CAD. TSTX.U is the same thing but it trades in USD, and TSTX.F trades in CAD but uses currency hedging to smooth out the CAD/USD exchange rate1.
  • TLTX/TLSX.U/TLTX.F: same idea as above, but these products are based on 20 year T-Bills, which would be considered “long” duration and are much more sensitive to changes in the prime interest rate.

They are brand spanking new (launched Oct 7, 2025), but have already paid out their first distributions at the end of October:

CAD ETF Distribution USD (.U) ETF DistributionHedged (.F) ETF Distribution
TSTX family (1-3y)0.140900.139910.13990
TLTX family (20y)0.160560.159430.15941

The TSTX family is paying 3.4% yield, which is way better than any CAD product I’ve evaluated previously2. It’s not as good as USD HISAs, but being able to get US-like interest rates in a Canadian denominated product is a cool thing. T-Bills of this duration are not super sensitive to changes in interest rates, but the 20y ones would be. TSTX is a product I’ll be keeping an eye on as an alternative to ZMMK, potentially, as long as the prime rate in the US remains significantly higher than Canada’s.

Reduced Fees for CNDX (S&P/TSX 60 index)

Global X was running a promo this year that I talked about previously, but they’ve set a new low price for their flagship Canadian index fund at 0.09% MER starting in 2026. (The MER is 0% at the moment). I don’t hold CNDX myself (I use XIC and VCN, which both include all of the TSX and costs 0.06%), but if you like to focus on the larger part of the Canadian market, you may want to take a look here.

  1. I don’t like hedging as a rule, as it just adds cost and I figure that over time, the USD/CAD exchange rate is reasonably stable. ↩︎
  2. And if these ETFs existed at the time, I probably wouldn’t have looked at them because they have a duration that’s a little too long for me to consider them “cash-like”. But I like my “cash” to be cashflow positive, with no downsides. ZMMK and ICSH aren’t guaranteed to do that, but their super-short average duration (90 days or so) makes it far more likely. ↩︎

The Cost of Asset Allocation ETFs

Readers will know that I’m a fan of the asset-allocation ETF. In fact, the vast majority of my retirement savings are dedicated to them. (New to the concept of asset allocation ETFs? Here’s an intro.)

Owning asset-allocation ETFs means you can quite literally invest and forget. The target asset allocations are maintained automatically for you, eliminating the all-too-common desire to tinker/experiment/play and mess with your returns in the process.

As with all things investing, there’s no such thing as a free lunch. This automatic asset re-allocation is reflected in the MER1 of the asset-allocation ETFs. So what’s this automatic management actually costing the holder of the all-in-one?

To work out the answer to that question, you have to look at how the asset-allocation ETF in question is built. Some people refer to asset allocation ETFs as “funds of funds” and this is actually quite an apt description, since most asset-allocation ETFs are just constructed by buying up index ETFs issued by the same company.

For example, iShares and TD each have an all-equity asset allocation ETF, named XEQT and TEQT2, respectively. Here’s what’s actually under the hood of each of them:

(I tried to keep the colours consistent between the two: red is Canadian equity, blue is US Equity, and other colours are international equity).

The thing about the MER of an all-in-one is that it already includes the MERs of the funds from which it is built. The tip-off is phrases like this one in iShares’ literature:


…MER includes all management fees and GST/HST paid by the fund for the period, and includes the fund’s proportionate share of the MER, if any, of any underlying fund in which the fund has invested…

https://www.blackrock.com/ca/investors/en/literature/product-brief/core-etf-portfolios-product-brief.pdf3

What this means is you can work out what the MER would be if you decided to simply manage the underlying funds yourself, and in so doing, figure out the premium that the all-in-one is adding to the mix.

I did this exercise, and here’s what I found:

XEQTTEQT
MER of component parts40.103%0.089%
All-in-one MER50.20%0.17%
MER premium for all-in-one60.097%0.081%
Annual premium cost per $1000 invested7$0.97$0.81

I offer a few takeaways from this analysis:

  • The MER costs I’m talking about here are lower than a factor of 10 (at least) that what’s charged by typical investment advisors and bank-backed mutual funds
  • The cost premium of the all-in-one is small, but it’s higher than I expected; even small percentage differences are greatly amplified when you work out (say) the 10 year cost of using these products.

The alternative of managing the constituent parts can be a cheapskate alternative and can save real money over time8, but one must beware of

  • The added complexity inherent in managing a portfolio of multiple ETFs. The XEQT/TEQT example is the simplest one; if you add bonds to the mix (e.g. XBAL/TBAL) you will need to add a few more ETFs to replicate the all-in-one. I used to manage my portfolio without using all-in-ones. I enjoyed it (you may have noticed I have a deep interest in investing). In retirement I have chosen to be practical and have attempted to create an environment that won’t be cognitively overwhelming as I get older.9
  • The greater likelihood of straying from the plan due to inaction or emotion kicking in. I myself didn’t put a lot of credence to this argument, but people smarter than me have pointed out that this is probably the one biggest factor that derails investment plans.
  1. The MER (Management Expense Ratio) is the cost of operating the ETF, expressed as a percentage. You don’t directly pay MER fees, but they reduce the overall returns of your investments. Lower MERs = more money for you. ↩︎
  2. No points for originality here ↩︎
  3. In teeny tiny letters at the bottom of page 1 ↩︎
  4. Weighted MER of each of the component ETFs. ↩︎
  5. You can find these on the ETF pages for XEQT and TEQT ↩︎
  6. Subtract 2 previous rows ↩︎
  7. Just multiply. Watch those decimal points, though. ↩︎
  8. I’m ignoring trading costs which aren’t zero but ought to be very small. Rebalancing assets is necessary of course but is perhaps a monthly, quarterly or annual exercise. ↩︎
  9. And even a portfolio just based on all-in-ones may prove to be too much to handle at some point. I’ve started to pay a bit more attention to the services offered by robo-advisors. ↩︎